...
| LDAP | SAML | Azure | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cloud or on-premise | Both - Some organizations do not want to expose LDAP to the internet so they choose on-premise. Read how LDAPs in the cloud is secure. | Both - Primarily used for cloud tenants who do not want to expose their LDAP directly to the internet | Both - provides a simple and secure way to access identity management (azure AD) in the cloud |
Are Uses/Roles automatically synchronizied with your Live Forms tenant(s) ? | Yes - Manual user/role sync (via frevvo csv upload for example) is not required. The frevvo server automatically gets users & roles from LDAP. | No - if “auth only” mode selected - Manual or automated csv uploads required on a regular basis Partial sync if discovery mode ( “auth only” off). User details and user’s roles are automatically discovered each time the user logs into the tenant. Thus the tenant can get out of sync with your IDP therefore manual or automated csv uploads on a regular basis are still recommended. | Yes - Manual user/role sync (via frevvo csv upload for example) is not required. The frevvo server automatically gets users & roles from Azure AD. |
| Single Sign On | Cloud - not available In-house - In-house - Must configure IIS using the IIS to Tomcat Connector | Yes | Yes |
| Authentication Only Mode Choice | No - You must change your IDP (LDAP in this case) to have roles you need in your frevvo workflow if they do not already exist. All user information is maintained in LDAP | Yes | Yes |
| Authentication Only = Yes | Not Supported | SAML handles authentication only - roles/users managed & maintained via the tenant Users/Roles UI. Changes made via the tenant Users/Roles UI do not get overridden when user logs in/out. Con - (1) All user information (email address) must be managed by the frevvo tenant admin. This can get out of sync with your IDP. Pro - You can add roles for frevvo workflow without having to edit your IDP | Azure handles authentication only. Authorization happens based on the roles defined in Azure AD. Authentication Only mode is recommended if you are using the Azure Security Manager. It is checked by default. |
| Authentication Only = No | This is the only mode allowed in this SM and this property does not even exist to change it. Groups needed for these user types in your IDP:
Users are discovered immediately the first time the tenant connects to the IDP and are automatically and always kept in sync without any manual intervention. | Groups needed for these user types in your IDP:
Users discovered when they log in. Changes made via the the tenant Users/Roles UI are overwritten if user logs out then in again. | The option to turn off Authentication Only mode is not available when configuring the Azure SAML tenant. |
| If your company uses LDAP as your IDP, do you need to install additional software to use this frevvo Security Manager? | No | Yes - (Either install one of the SAML 2.0 Implementations such as ADFS or use a cloud provider such as Okta, and configure it to talk to your LDAP server) | Yes (You must purchase Azure AD in the cloud) |
| Can I embed frevvo forms/flows into my website with this Security Manager? | Yes | Yes - if the visibility of the form is set to Public. Yes - if the visibility of the form is set to Public in Tenant and the user is already authenticated to SAML No - if the visibility of the form is set to Public in Tenant and the user is NOT already authenticated to SAML. This is because frevvo must direct the user to the IDP login screen and the browser will not allow loading the IDP login page in frevvo's form iframe. | Yes - if the visibility of the form is set to Public. Yes - if the visibility of the form is set to Public in Tenant and the user is already authenticated to Azure SAML. No - if the visibility of the form is set to Public in Tenant and the user is NOT already authenticated to SAML. This is because frevvo must direct the user to the IDP login screen and the browser will not allow loading the IDP login page in frevvo's form iframe. |
| What does frevvo support? | Microsoft AD, Open LDAP | Shibboleth, ADFS, Okta, Centrify, Google and any other software that implements the SAML 2.0 protocol | There is no other implementation of Azure AD then Azure AD |
| What does frevvo certify? | Microsoft AD | none | Azure AD |
| Do you need your own Configuration Specialist for your IDP | Yes | Yes | Yes |
...